The House of Representatives has passed a bill that would effectively remove private lenders from the student loan industry and would instead turn this enormous task over to the Department of Education.
The vote was 253-171, largely along party lines. Republicans had fought the measure, saying it would rob students and schools of choice and lead to job losses (private lenders would still be needed in some capacity to service loans).
The Senate already has begun work on similar legislation. Democrats may need to gain the support of at least one Republican to avoid a filibuster threat, but the GOP already is drawing comparisons to the healthcare debate by describing the bill as another government takeover.
Private lenders currently make about 75 percent of student loans, which is a growing industry. Because of rising tuition costs and lower contributions from cash-strapped families, total loan volume was $74 billion during the 2008-09 school year, up 13 percent from the year before.
The Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) is the single largest source of college loans. These are issued by private lenders but backed by the government, which also pays the interest while a student is in school or in deferment. The legislation effectively cuts out the private lenders as middlemen.
"The choice before us is clear: We can either keep sending these
subsidies to banks or we can start sending them directly to students,"
said Rep. George Miller, the California Democrat who sponsored the bill as chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee.
How much would an all-government student-loan system save? As The National Journal's Eliza Krigman notes here, the Congressional Budget Office initially said savings would amount to $87 billion over 10 years, allowing more money to go to Pell grants for low-income students, as well as early-learning programs, school renovations, and historically black colleges. But a follow-up examination by the CBO found that once likely defaults are taken into account, savings would be more like $47 billion.
Landon Hall – A freelance writer in Silicon Valley, Landon was a reporter, sports writer and editor at The Associated Press in Portland and New York City from 1997-2006.